Nattering Naybob: I was all gung-ho this past week (justifiably I think) about the 40th anniversary of Secretariat’s 1973 Belmont Stakes victory. But I would be terribly remiss if I did not also acknowledge something even more important than Secretariat that also happened earlier in June, 69 years ago to be exact: The invasion of Normandy by the Allied Forces, otherwise known as D-Day, June 4, 1944.
Far be it from me, Red Ranger, to wax poetic about the importance of this event. That has been done, with far greater eloquence than I ever could muster, by scores of learned and studied historians. I will only say that any freedom we now have as a Nation is due directly to this event and to the sacrifices of all the men and women who served in World War II and all the other armed conflicts in which our country has engaged, even ones that may not have been as “popular” or well-executed.
For all our citizenry’s chest-thumping and flag waving about “supporting our troops”, we still do far less than we should in all aspects of helping members of the military and their loved ones. The mere fact that a backlog of up to two years exists in the VA to even review veterans’ disability claims, is a story so unfathomable and irresponsible that it should be reported on every single day by the news media. Some outlets have brought this issue to the fore (Rachel Maddow, for one), but not enough and not vigorously enough. I am totally prepared to lay his share of the blame for this, on our Commander-in-Chief, of whom I am a loyal supporter.
Unfortunately, the vocabulary of our perception of the military has been reduced to such things as teary-eyed, well-orchestrated surprise “re-unions” of soldiers with their little children, broadcast on TV and even now Diamond Vision screens at baseball games. While these scenes choke me up as much as anybody, they are part of a mis-guided trend towards sanitizing warfare and its consequences. Recent studies that take a harder look at these stunts have suggested that being re-united with their father or mother in such a public way can have long-lasting negative effects on the children involved, as this article by Tara Swords summarizes in the Washington Post.
Off my soapbox now and back to D-Day. There is a terrific website called the Doing History Project that I have come across that has loads of information about D-Day, its planning and importance. On this site is included a draft of a poignant letter that Dwight D. Eisenhower, Allied Commander of the D-Day operation, had drafted and was prepared to deliver in the unfortunate event that the mission had failed:
“Our landings have failed and I have withdrawn the troops. My decision to attack at this time and place was based on the best information available. The troops, the air and the Navy did all that bravery could do. If any blame or fault attaches to the attempt it is mine alone.”
It is no wonder that Dwight Eisenhower has been held in increasingly higher esteem in recent years.
Of course Steven Spielberg’s brilliant “Saving Private Ryan” is a recent example of paying homage to the real-life experiences of D-Day. Many veterans of the actual invasion have said that “Private Ryan” replicates the experience of that horrible day, and the days after, better than any film ever has. To think that this film was beaten out by “Shakespeare in Love” for the Best Film award at the 1999 Academy Awards, is not only the greatest injustice in the history of award ceremonies, but perhaps in the history of the world at large.
The Red Ranger: First off let me say that I actually thought “Shakespeare in Love” was a very good movie and I am no fan of Gwyneth Paltrow. Is it better than Saving Private Ryan, I don’t know. Outside of the opening sequence SPR seemed to drag on a little too long for me. Perhaps there was some backlash against the whole Spielberg/Hanks thing.
As far as veterans go they should get the best care possible without a doubt. However, the cynic in me is starting to believe that there is an epidemic of PTSD claims. Obviously, what some of these veterans go through is beyond anything you or I will see in our lifetime. However, these people know this going in and should be ready for it. In reality it is not always the brightest that go into the military (however, they are probably the bravest). My hypothesis is that when some of these veterans get out of the military and are unable to obtain a job in the civilian community they fall back upon PTSD as a way to justify their inability to prosper in the civilian world. Clearly, this does not apply to everyone but I am sure there is some percentage who attribute their issues to PTSD and there is always some doctor willing to concur.
If only our current leaders took responsibility like Eisenhower did instead of highlighting their lack of knowledge or recusing themselves. Just goes to show how far we have fallen in terms of leaders and their values.
Nattering Naybob: The whole question of PTSD is a tricky one. It is true that there are more PTSD claims than in the Vietnam War, say, because it was only designated as an official condition in 1980. Whether or not it’s being abused, I don’t know how that can be measured although I have no doubt that there are some people who claim to have it just so they can get sympathy, related benefits, etc. The same can be said for just about any disease or condition. Many people think that autism is over-diagnosed. I remember during the 80’s and 90’s, Chronic Fatigue Syndrome was all the rage, and it was no doubt diagnosed many times as the cause for a lot of people’s inability to stop watching TV and get off the couch.
Here is the link to the official “PTSD” page on the website of the Department of Veterans Affairs. It is rather lengthy and a bit technical at times, but I think it only fair to include the link in case anyone reading this blog wants to learn more about it especially as it pertains to veterans.
I am not a Gwyneth Paltrow fan either but I thought she was good in the Iron Man movies. I think people say that a lot about her: “I am not a fan of hers, but she was good in such and such a movie”. It’s probably her off-screen persona that people dislike, including me. There is just something about her that makes people want to smush a whip cream pie into her face.
The Red Ranger: I do remember Chronic Fatigue Syndrome. I think I caught that after your 500th rant about how great Obama was.
I also agree about autism. It seems like every kid who may be a little slower learning than the others has autism or at least a mild form of it. I think it is a way for parents not having to face up to the fact that their kid might just not be as smart as others. Compared to you and me everyone has some form of autism.
I have not seen the Iron Man movies (yes, you have found the one person who hasn’t seen them). A whip cream pie to the face would be nice to see.
Nattering Naybob: I find it necessary to emphasize that I and presumably you, Red Ranger, acknowledge many genuine cases of autism exist, and that it is a serious condition. That being said, I see your point about the futility of anyone holding themselves up against our record of intelligence, insight, and yes, humility.